 |
| 1. Teutopolis Wooden Shoes |
 |
| 2. Southwestern Piasa Birds |
 |
| 3. Illinois Valley Grey Ghosts |
 |
| 4. Lincoln-Way East Griffins |
 |
| 5. Judah Tribe |
 |
| 6. Monticello Sages |
 |
| 7. Lincoln-Way No. Phoenix |
 |
| 8. Polo Marcos |
 |
| 9. Cobden Appleknockers |
 |
| 10. Argo Fighting Argonauts |
 |
| 11. Fisher Bunnies |
 |
| 12. Genoa-Kingston Cogs |
 |
| 13. Hoopeston Cornjerkers |
 |
| 14. Roosevelt Rough Riders |
 |
| 15. DeKalb Barbs |
 |
| 16. Elk Grove Grenadiers |
More favorite Illinois high school mascots submitted by readers:
 |
 |
 |
 |